U.S.: Think Tank Calls for 'Bold Leap Forward' in India Ties

• by Jim Lobe* (washington)
• Wednesday, October 20, 2010
• Inter Press Service

In a report released here Wednesday, the Center for a New American Security (CNAS) expressed concerns that the momentum in building such ties that was gained during the two previous U.S. administrations 'has stalled' and that both countries need to take concrete steps to restore it.

The 12-page report, entitled 'Natural Allies: A Blueprint for the Future of U.S.-India Relations,' calls on Washington, among other things, to publicly support India's permanent membership in an enlarged U.N. Security Council; seek a broad expansion of bilateral trade and investment; 'greatly expand the security relationship and boost defense trade'; and liberalise U.S. export controls on goods that have both a civil and military application.

For its part, India should, among other steps, act quickly to fully implement its Civil Nuclear Agreement with the U.S.; raise its limits on foreign investment; reduce barriers to defence and other forms of trade; enhance its rules for protecting intellectual property; and cooperate more closely with the U.S. in international fora, according to the CNAS task force that approved the report.

The report, which was released amid a three-day 'strategic dialogue' here between officials of the U.S. and India's traditional rival, Pakistan, also comes two weeks before Obama's scheduled visit to India, part of an Asian tour that will also take him to Indonesia; South Korea, where both he and Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh are expected to play key roles at the Group of 20 (G-20) summit; and Japan, which is hosting the annual Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit.

This week's U.S.-Pakistan meeting is expected to result in Washington's agreement to provide a five-year, more than two-billion-dollar aid package for Islamabad, in addition to the nearly two billion dollars it is supplying the Pakistani army this year.

India has historically opposed U.S. military assistance and sales to its western neighbour, fearing that the aid will eventually be directed against it. The two nuclear-armed countries fought three wars between 1947 and 1971 and another limited conflict in the Kargil district in disputed Kashmir in 1999.

Washington is thus seeking assurances from Islamabad that all of the current and forthcoming assistance will be used only for counterinsurgency and counterterrorist operations against Islamist militants, particularly along Pakistan's border with Afghanistan where Washington and its NATO allies have been engaged in a nine-year conflict against the Taliban, al Qaeda, and their affiliates.

The new aid package appears designed primarily to induce greater cooperation from Pakistan in denying safe haven and other forms of support to the militants, some of whom are also closely associated with anti-Indian groups; among them, Lashkar-e-Taiba, which two years ago carried out a commando attack on high-profile targets in Mumbai in which nearly 200 people were killed.

While the CNAS report does not focus on Pakistan, it stresses that the U.S. and India should 'deepen their dialogue' on both Pakistan and Afghanistan and expand their anti-terrorist cooperation pursuant to a memorandum of understanding signed by the two countries in July.

The Obama White House has sought to make India a major diplomatic priority, but its preoccupation with events in Afghanistan and Pakistan has largely overshadowed those efforts.

Last November, Singh was the guest of honour at Obama's first state dinner since his inauguration 11 months before and, in November, the president participated personally in the opening session of the two countries' first 'strategic dialogue' held at the State Department last June.

'Never has there been a moment when India and America mattered more to one another, and never has there been a moment when partnership with India and America mattered more to the rest of the globe,' said then-Undersecretary of State William Burns at the time.

The CNAS report, however, suggests that progress in forging that partnership is, in its words, 'falling short of its promise'.

The non-partisan task force that produced the report was co- chaired by former Deputy Defence Secretary Richard Armitage and former Undersecretary of State under both George W. Bush and Obama, Nicholas Burns.

Task force members included leading experts and former South Asia policy-makers, including Stephen Cohen of the Brookings Institution; former Assistant Secretaries of State for South Asian Affairs Karl Inderfurth and Teresita Schaffer; former U.S. Ambassador to New Delhi Frank Wisner, and Ashley Tellis, a former Bush adviser now with the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

CNAS, which, along with the Brookings Institution and the Center for American Progress, has played a key role in staffing the upper foreign policy ranks in the Obama administration, also included a number of its experts on the task force.

The report asserts that Israel's 'rise to global power is … in America's interest', and that Washington should not only seek a closer relationship with Delhi, 'but actively assist its further emergence as a great power'.

Both countries have a 'vital interest' in maintaining a stable balance of power in Asia,' according to the report.

'Neither seeks containment of China, but the likelihood of a peaceful Chinese rise increases if it ascends in a region where the great democratic powers are also strong,' it said, adding that India will also 'play an increasingly vital role in addressing virtually all major global challenges', from international trade and finance, to energy and climate change, to nuclear non-proliferation and the exploration of space.

The report put special emphasis on what it called 'an expanded U.S.-India military partnership' and expressed disappointment that 'bureaucratic inertia in both countries' has hampered growth in that the defence sector.

During his Nov. 5-9 visit, Obama hopes to oversee agreements totalling between $10 and $12 billion in U.S. sales to India, most of it in the form of advanced weapons, particularly in military-transport aircraft, the Wall Street Journal reported earlier this week. The CNAS report also noted the ongoing competition for India's next fleet of tactical fighter aircraft, which could earn U.S. companies as much as $10 billion.

The administration also hopes to shore up a landmark 2008 deal that would enable U.S. companies to build nuclear power plants in India. Those companies, however, have been discouraged by the Indian Parliament's failure to enact legislation that would exempt manufacturers from liability for accidents.

That failure, warned the report, 'will undermine the most important agreement the two countries have negotiated and pose grave risks for the relationship at the political level.'

*Jim Lobe's blog on U.S. foreign policy can be read at http://www.lobelog.com.

© Inter Press Service (2010) — All Rights ReservedOriginal source: Inter Press Service

Where next?

Advertisement