Trinidad Scraps Controversial Smelter

•  port of spain
• Saturday, October 30, 2010
• Inter Press Service

'In addition to the health and environmental risk, there is also serious concern as to Alutrint's viability and the optimal use of our gas. This project shall cease and an alternative strategy will be put into place for the southwest peninsula,' Dookeran said.

The proposed 125,000 metric-tonnes-per-year aluminum smelter complex had been fiercely defended by the Patrick Manning government until it was swept out of power in May. It would have resulted in the Brazilian conglomerate Votorantim Group having a 40 percent stake while the Trinidad and Tobago government held the remaining 60 percent.

China's Exim Bank was providing the $66.6 million dollar credit facility for construction of the project, which was halted last year after the High Court ruled that the decision of the Environmental Management Authority (EMA) to grant a Certificate of Environmental Clearance was illegal. The Manning government appealed and a ruling was expected soon. But the government's new position has now made the ruling academic.

Energy Minister Carol Seepersad-Bachan said that plants to manufacture inorganic chemicals, glass, alternative energy- industry plastics and agro-business products were likely to take the place of the smelter plant, which environmentalists said would have been highly toxic and would have affected the health of area residents. 'Despite what we have been told that the plant would have been a modern facility and safe, no one was saying how we were going to get rid of the waste generated,' environmentalist Dr. Wayne Kublalsingh told IPS.

'Because of Alutrint, residents of La Brea and environs would have to be tested for cancer every six months,' he added, referring to a 2008 medical monitoring plan by the Caribbean Health Research Council and the International Institute for Healthcare and Human Development.

Not everyone agrees. David Renwick, who was given a national award in 2008 for his coverage of energy issues in Trinidad and Tobago, said that 'the fact is that aluminium smelting poses no threat these days either to health or the environment - as real experts from countries that have produced aluminium for decades have repeatedly testified.' Health questions aside, at the parliamentary debate on the budget that ended Thursday, Planning and Development Minister Mary King said that the project simply did not make economic sense.

© Inter Press Service (2010) — All Rights ReservedOriginal source: Inter Press Service

Where next?

Advertisement